EN
Start freeStartContinue the courseContinue
A four-funnel liner steams at full speed at night under a starry sky; ahead of her, the dark outline of an iceberg.
A four-funnel liner steams at full speed at night; ahead, the outline of an iceberg. This is not an image of the event or of the moment of the collision. Illustration: Náutica Visual

Which rules would the Titanic breach today? COLREGs and SOLAS

We lay today’s COLREGs and SOLAS rules over the Titanic’s night: speed, look-out, boats and rockets. A verdict rule by rule, plus a 3D scene.

Two, mainly. The first is the safe-speed rule, Rule 6 of the COLREGs (RIPA in Spain): the Titanic was making about 22 knots, at night, after ice warnings by radio, and she sighted the iceberg about 450 metres off. The second is SOLAS regulation III/21: she carried boat places for 1,178 of the 2,201 people on board, and today she would have to carry them for 125 per cent. Another part of that night would pass today’s test: there was an officer on the bridge and a radio watch, and the lookout was not the helmsman. Whether the look-out was proper is another question, and the reports do not let us decide it. The COLREGs rules on risk of collision and on action to avoid it, on their wording, do not even come into play: an iceberg is not a vessel.

One warning that holds for the whole text: none of these rules existed in 1912. They were written afterwards, and SOLAS itself was born, according to the IMO, as a response to this wreck. Under the British law of the day the ship was in order, and the British court said so. Here we set the text the BOE (Spain’s official gazette) publishes today beside the facts fixed by the official reports of 1912. The verdicts are our analysis: they speak of what was done and not of who did it, and no investigating body stands behind them.

The incident at a glance

speed when the lookout gave the warning
≈22knots
distance at which the iceberg was sighted (500 yards, according to the court)
≈450m
in the boats, for 2,201 people on board
1,178places
from the collision to the sinking
2 h 40 min
  • Conditions: a clear, moonless night, no wind, a flat sea, air at about 0 °C
  • Consequences: damage of about 300 ft (91 m) along the starboard side, below the waterline; sinking at 02:20 on 15 April; according to the British report’s table, 711 of the 2,201 people were saved
  • Investigations: the British report of 30 July 1912 and the US Senate report of 28 May 1912; on the Californian, the MAIB’s reappraisal of 1992
  • Report: Source of the data: transcription of the British report by the Titanic Inquiry Project; accessed on 16 November 2026. Times are ship’s time.

The four minutes before the collision

Illustrative night reconstruction: a four-funnel liner with her lights on and, ahead of her, an iceberg.
Illustrative reconstruction
Data:
the track, time, speed and heading of TITANIC (and its heading arrow), by dead reckoning: course and speed from the reports; between two legs, the values change continuously.
Illustrative iceberg:
its shape, size and exact position are an illustration; its distance and bearing come from the reconstruction’s assumptions.
Illustration:
the models of the liner and the iceberg, the sea and the stars; the scene does not reproduce what could be seen that night.

There is no record of positions from that night. The track is calculated by dead reckoning, from the course and speed that the reports give. The scene puts the warning 45 seconds before the collision. That is our own estimate: the 37 seconds the Olympic took to turn two points, plus a few seconds for the warning and the order. At 22 knots, 500 yards take about 40 seconds. The iceberg is an illustration: no report describes its shape, its size or its colour. The British report puts the collision at 23:40 and the Senate report at 23:46; the scene follows the British one.

Illustrative reconstruction by Náutica Visual from the data in the British report of 1912. It does not reproduce the facts exactly, it does not replace the official reports and it does not determine responsibility.

Reconstruction as text
  1. 23:36:00 The Titanic is making about 22 knots on course 266° (S 86° W true), the same since 17:50. A clear, moonless night, with a flat sea. Several ice warnings have been received on board.
  2. 23:39:15 Shortly before 23:40, the lookout in the crow’s nest strikes the gong three times and telephones the bridge: “Iceberg right ahead”. The British court accepted that it was sighted at about 500 yards (about 450 m). The time of this mark is our own estimate; the reports do not give it.
  3. 23:39:45 The officer of the watch has ordered “Hard-a-starboard” and, by the engine-room telegraph, “Stop. Full speed astern”. With the tiller orders of 1912, ‘starboard’ sends the bow to port. The bow is already falling away to port.
  4. 23:40:00 The bow has fallen away about two points (22.5°) and the hull touches the ice with the starboard bow, below the waterline.
  5. 23:40:10 The side runs along the iceberg. The damage extends about 300 ft (91 m) and, according to the report, happens in under ten seconds.
  1. From 22:00 to the lookout’s warning. 22 knots after ice warnings.

    What happened: The Titanic is making about 22 knots on course S 86° W true (266°), the same since 17:50. The night is clear and moonless, and the sea is flat. Several ice warnings have come in by radio; two of them reached the captain. At 22:00 the watch is handed over with the warning that the ship is entering the ice region.

    What the report says: The report records that no order was given to reduce speed. Asked whether it was excessive, it answers “Yes”, and it attributes the loss to a collision with an iceberg, brought about by the excessive speed at which the ship was being navigated. (British report of 1912, «Speed of the Ship», respuesta 14 y conclusión)

    Rule that comes into play (our analysis) and lesson: Rule 6 comes into play: a speed that allows effective manoeuvring and a stop within a distance suited to the circumstances. Among the factors to be weighed are visibility and the proximity of navigational dangers. Our verdict, on today’s text: she would breach it. Course lesson: Look-out, speed and risk

  2. Shortly before 23:40. “Iceberg right ahead”.

    What happened: The lookout in the crow’s nest, about 29 m above the water, strikes the gong three times and telephones the bridge: “Iceberg right ahead”. The court accepted that the ice was sighted at about 500 yards (about 450 m). There are two lookouts in the crow’s nest, without binoculars; nobody is at the stem. The time of this mark is our own estimate: the reports do not give it.

    What the report says: The report considers that the look-out was not sufficient: in those circumstances there should have been an extra lookout in the bows and an officer watching from each side of the bridge. Asked whether the lookouts had binoculars and whether there were searchlights, it answers “No”. (British report of 1912, «The Collision», respuestas 10 y 11)

    Rule that comes into play (our analysis) and lesson: Rule 5 comes into play: a proper look-out by sight and hearing, using all available means that are appropriate to the circumstances. Our verdict: cannot be determined. There was a look-out; the reports do not make clear whether the binoculars were ‘available’ (disponibles) in the rule’s sense. Course lesson: Look-out, speed and risk

  3. Almost at the same time as the warning. Hard over and engines astern.

    What happened: The officer of the watch orders “Hard-a-starboard” and, by the engine-room telegraph, “Stop. Full speed astern”; he closes the watertight doors from the bridge. With the tiller orders of 1912, ‘starboard’ sends the bow to port. By the time the ice is touched, the bow has fallen away about two points (22.5°). The time of the order is our own estimate.

    What the report says: The report places the orders almost at the same time as the warning. It takes from a trial with the Olympic that a turn of two points took about 37 seconds and 466 yards, and records what the officer of the watch said afterwards: he meant to go round the iceberg, but it was too close. (British report of 1912, «The Collision»)

    Rule that comes into play (our analysis) and lesson: On its wording, Rule 8 does not come into play: it deals with collision between vessels, and an iceberg is not one. What the bridge did matches what its paragraph e) describes: reduce speed or stop by reversing the means of propulsion. Course lesson: Look-out, speed and risk

  4. 23:40 (British report); 23:46 (Senate report). The side scrapes the ice.

    What happened: The hull touches the iceberg with the starboard bow, below the waterline. The damage extends about 300 ft (91 m), from the forepeak to boiler rooms 6 and 5, and happens in under ten seconds. There are 2,201 people on board and the 20 boats have 1,178 places.

    What the report says: The report puts the damage about 10 ft (3 m) above the keel, with none higher. It finds the 1912 law complied with: that law worked out boats by tonnage and asked for places for 962 people. It recommends working them out by the people on board. (British report of 1912, «Extent of the Damage», respuesta 2 y recomendación 6)

    Rule that comes into play (our analysis) and lesson: SOLAS regulation III/21 comes into play: boats for half of the people on each side and liferafts for another 25 per cent. For 2,201 people that is about 2,752 places. Our verdict: she would breach it today. This regulation does not apply to a pleasure yacht not engaged in trade (SOLAS I/3). Course lesson: Abandoning ship and survival

Dead-reckoning track of the TITANIC between 23:36 and 23:40 · OverviewThe liner’s track calculated by dead reckoning: a constant course to the west and, at the end, a turn to port up to the place of the collision. The illustrative iceberg appears as a dashed line.Overview23:36:0023:39:1523:40:00N5 cables (926 m)Illustrative icebergDead-reckoning track of the TITANIC between 23:36 and 23:40 · Close-up of the last minutesThe liner’s track calculated by dead reckoning: a constant course to the west and, at the end, a turn to port up to the place of the collision. The illustrative iceberg appears as a dashed line.Close-up of the last minutes23:39:1523:39:2323:39:3223:40:0023:40:10N1 cable (185 m)Heading (dead reckoning)

In four minutes the Titanic covers almost a mile and a half in a straight line, on course 266°. The inset shows the last 45 seconds: the bow falls away to port and the starboard side meets the ice. The track is a dead-reckoning estimate and the iceberg is an illustration.

What the bridge knew

What matters for today’s rules is what was known before the collision. The British report reconstructs it hour by hour.

  1. 09:00
    Warning from the CaroniaIcebergs, growlers and field ice in 42° N, between 49° and 51° W. The captain acknowledges it.British report, ‘Messages Received’
  2. 13:42
    Warning from the BalticAnother steamer has passed icebergs and a lot of ice in 41°51′ N, 49°52′ W. The captain acknowledges it; the message does not reach the chart room until 19:15.British report, ‘Messages Received’
  3. 17:50
    Change of courseFrom S 62° W to S 86° W true. The court judged it too small to be due to the ice warnings.British report, answers 8 and 9
  4. 19:15
    Darkness aheadThe first officer has a forecastle hatch closed: ice is near and he wants “everything dark before the bridge”.British report, ‘Messages Received’
  5. 21:30
    Order to the lookoutsThe crow’s nest is told to watch for ice, above all small ice and growlers.British report, answer 10
  6. 21:40
    Warning from the MesabaA lot of pack ice and a large number of big icebergs between 41°25′ and 42° N, 49° and 50°30′ W. It reaches neither the captain nor the officers.British report, ‘Messages Received’
  7. 23:40
    The collisionTime from the British report; the Senate report gives 23:46.British report, ‘The Collision’

According to the court, the captain and three of his officers knew that afternoon that the ship was entering a region where ice might be expected. The report records no order to ease the engines.

Verdict, rule by rule

Today’s rule What it asks What the Titanic did Verdict
COLREGs, Rule 6 A speed that allows effective manoeuvring and a stop within an appropriate distance About 22 knots at night, after ice warnings Would breach
COLREGs, Rule 2 a) Take the precautions that the ordinary practice of seamen or the special circumstances of the case may require Course and speed unchanged, as was the custom Would breach
COLREGs, Rule 5 A proper look-out with all available means Two lookouts in the crow’s nest and an officer on the bridge; no binoculars Cannot be determined
COLREGs, Rules 7 and 8 Judge the risk of collision and manoeuvre in good time The obstacle was an iceberg Do not apply, on their wording
SOLAS III/21 Boats for 50 per cent of the people on each side and liferafts for another 25 per cent (125 per cent in all) 1,178 places for 2,201 people Would breach
SOLAS III/19 and III/37 Muster the passengers on departure, hold drills, and have the muster list ready before sailing No boat drill on the voyage; list of boat stations posted days later, according to the Senate report Would breach
COLREGs, Rule 37 and Annex IV Use the distress signals of the annex, among them rockets throwing red stars About eight rockets with white stars, which are not in the annex Would breach, in colour only
SOLAS IV/12 A continuous radio watch for distress, urgency and safety traffic; today on specific channels Two radio operators; the station received warnings all day Would comply in substance; today’s channels did not exist
STCW VIII/2 and its Code Officer of the watch on the bridge; lookout and helmsman separate people So it was Would comply
SOLAS II-1/8 Withstand a calculated side damage: for this ship, about 8 m Damage of about 91 m Cannot be determined

We assume a passenger ship on an international voyage that is not short. The verdicts are an informational analysis by Náutica Visual, not legal advice.

Was she too fast for what she could see?

Rule 6 requires a vessel to proceed at all times at a safe speed, one that allows proper and effective action to avoid collision and a stop within a distance suited to the circumstances and conditions of the momentCOLREGs, Rule 6 (BOE, in Spanish).

The data come from the British report. The ship was making about 22 knots and, according to the report, no order was given to reduce speed. By the time of contact the bow had fallen away two points, 22.5°. In a trial with the Olympic, a turn of two points took about 37 seconds and 466 yards. With a few more seconds to give the order, the court put the distance at which the iceberg was sighted at 500 yards, about 450 metres. That is under two ship lengths, by our own calculation. The 22.5° turn took up almost all of that distance; the stopping distance at that speed does not appear in the reports.

The rule lists the factors to be weighed, and two of them pointed to going slower. One is visibility. The night was clear, but moonless and with a flat sea, and the report records that this was discussed on the bridge: with no wind there would be no breaking water at the foot of the ice to give it away. According to the testimony the report records, the second officer expected to see it at a mile and a half or two miles. It was seen at a quarter of a mile. The other factor is the proximity of dangers to navigation, and ice had been reported. The rule has ice in mind: it names it among the things a radar may fail to detect in time.

A third factor was attended to. The rule mentions the glare of a ship’s own lights, and at 19:15 the first officer had a hatch closed to keep it dark ahead of the bridge.

Verdict: she would breach Rule 6 today. In 1912 the rule did not exist and the court did not apply it. Its conclusion is separate: asked whether the speed was excessive, it answered “Yes”, and it attributed the loss to a collision with an iceberg, brought about by the excessive speed at which the ship was being navigated.

Was doing what everyone did enough?

In 1912, in clear weather, liners held course and speed in the ice region and trusted to see the danger in time. According to the British report, the practice was a quarter of a century old or more, and experience had endorsed it: it had caused no accidents. According to the report, the shipping line had also given no special instructions about icebergs. That is why the court did not blame the captain. It added a sentence for those who would come after: “What was a mistake in the case of the ‘Titanic’ would without doubt be negligence in any similar case in the future”British report of 1912, ‘Action that should have been taken’..

That future now has a rule number. Rule 2 a) reminds us that complying with the rest of the regulations does not exempt anyone from the consequences of neglecting any precaution that the ordinary practice of seamen or the special circumstances of the case may requireCOLREGs, Rule 2 (BOE, in Spanish). The special circumstances were the ice warnings on the ship’s route, and the precaution they called for was not taken. Verdict: she would breach it today. That is a judgement on what was done, not a finding that anyone was negligent.

Was the look-out good enough?

Rule 5 asks for a proper look-out by sight and hearing, using all available means that are appropriate to the circumstances and conditions of the momentCOLREGs, Rule 5 (BOE, in Spanish).

There was a look-out. Two lookouts manned the crow’s nest, about 29 metres above the water, with orders to watch for ice, and an officer was on the bridge. The lookouts had no binoculars, the ship carried no searchlights and nobody was posted at the stem. The 1912 court did not think it enough: it wrote that the look-out was not sufficient and that there should have been an extra lookout in the bows and an officer watching from each side of the bridge.

Verdict: it cannot be determined. ‘Proper’ (eficaz in the BOE text) and ‘appropriate’ (apropiados) are words that call for judgement. The reports say the binoculars were not issued, but do not make clear whether they were ‘available’ (disponibles) in the rule’s sense. What does fit today’s standard is that the lookout and the helmsman were different people, as the STCW Code requiresSTCW Code, section A-VIII/2, BOE-A-2012-7389 (in Spanish).

Why do the rules on manoeuvring not count?

Rule 7 deals with risk of collision and Rule 8 with action to avoid it. Both speak of vessels, and Rule 3 defines a ‘vessel’ (buque in the BOE text) as a craft used as a means of transport on waterCOLREGs, Rules 3, 7 and 8 (BOE, in Spanish). An iceberg is not one. Verdict: on their wording, they do not apply.

The bridge’s reaction, all the same, is the one Rule 8 e) describes: reduce speed or stop by reversing the means of propulsion. The report places the orders almost at the moment of the warning: helm hard over, “Stop. Full speed astern”, and the watertight doors closed from the bridge. One detail puzzles the modern reader. The order was “Hard-a-starboard”, and with the tiller orders of the day that sent the bow to port, as the MAIB explains.

The text of SOLAS chapter V that we have read has no speed limit near ice either. We looked for one and found two other things: the North Atlantic ice patrol (V/6), which did not exist in 1912, and the duty to warn other ships when you encounter ice (V/31)SOLAS, chapter V, BOE-A-2002-24637 (in Spanish). Speed near ice still depends on Rule 6.

How many boat places would SOLAS ask for today?

The Titanic carried 20 boats with 1,178 places for 2,201 people. For a passenger ship on an international voyage that is not short, SOLAS regulation III/21 requires boats with places for half of the people on each side and, in addition, liferafts for another 25 per cent; the Administration may allow part of the boats to be replaced by liferafts of equivalent capacitySOLAS III/21, BOE-A-1998-26305 (in Spanish). For 2,201 people that comes to about 2,752 places. She would be 1,574 places short.

places required by British law in 1912
962
places the Titanic carried
1,178
people on board
2,201
places SOLAS III/21 asks for today
≈2,752

Verdict: she would breach regulation III/21 today.

The drills are the same story. On a voyage of more than 24 hours, regulation III/19 requires the newly embarked passengers to be mustered before departure or immediately afterSOLAS III/19, 2013 amendments, BOE-A-2015-7394 (in Spanish), and III/37 wants the muster list prepared before sailing. In the parts of the reports that we have read, no muster of passengers on departure is recorded, and the British report says there was no boat drill on the voyage. According to the Senate report, the only drill was the lowering of two boats in port, part of the crew joined only a few hours before sailing, and the list of boat stations was posted days later. Verdict: she would breach them today.

What about the white rockets?

The Titanic fired about eight distress rockets that threw off white stars. In 1912 any colour would do. Rule 37 now tells a vessel in distress to use the signals in Annex IV, and among them the annex lists rockets or shells throwing red starsCOLREGs, Rule 37 and Annex IV (BOE, in Spanish). According to the MAIB, the rules did not require red until 1948. Verdict: she would breach it today, in colour only. The signal was used for what it is for: the danger was real and help was needed.

What would she comply with today?

Four of today’s obligations would pose no problem:

  • Officer on the bridge. STCW requires the officer of the watch to be physically present on the bridge or in places directly related to itSTCW, regulation VIII/2, BOE-A-2012-3857 (in Spanish). The officer was there, and gave the orders.
  • Radio watch. SOLAS IV/12 asks for a continuous radio watch, today on specific channels and frequenciesSOLAS IV/12, BOE-A-2024-5063 (in Spanish). There were two radio operators and the station received warnings all day: with the means of the time, the substance is met. That the Mesaba’s warning did not reach the bridge is another matter, which that regulation does not cover.
  • Ice warning to other ships. The duty in regulation V/31 arises when a master encounters ice. According to the reports, the Titanic had not met it before 23:40, so the regulation did not come into play.
  • Distress signals. They were used only in real danger, as regulation V/35 requires.

Would the hull survive under today’s rule?

Here the surprise runs the other way: the calculation of this rule starts from damage far shorter than what the ice caused. SOLAS regulation II-1/8 requires a passenger ship with 400 people or more to withstand side damage of 0.03 times her subdivision length, and not less than 3 mSOLAS II-1/8, BOE-A-2009-12852 (in Spanish). With the Titanic’s registered length (we have not calculated her subdivision length), that comes to about 8 metres. The ice opened about 91. On our reading, this regulation alone does not require a ship to withstand damage of that length. As we have not calculated the subdivision indices the standard uses, the verdict stays at cannot be determined.

The British report ended with 24 recommendations. Several of them have a rule close by today.

The 1912 report recommended What exists today
Work out boat and liferaft places by the people on board and not by tonnage, with room for everyone SOLAS III/21
Boat, fire and watertight-door drills SOLAS III/19 for boat and fire drills; watertight-door drills fall under another regulation, which we have not read
A radio watch kept day and night SOLAS IV/12
At night, with ice reported, a moderate speed or a change of course In part, the safe speed of COLREGs Rule 6; the SOLAS chapter V that we have read sets no limit
An international conference on these matters The SOLAS Convention, whose first version was adopted in 1914

What does this mean for you on a pleasure craft?

The COLREGs apply to all vessels on the high seas and in the waters connected with it that are navigable by seagoing vessels. On our reading of Rule 3, its definition of ‘vessel’ also covers a pleasure craftCOLREGs, Rules 1 and 3 (BOE, in Spanish). Rules 2, 5 and 6 then bind you just as they bind a liner: at night, a speed that lets you steer clear of or stop for what you see late, and somebody keeping a look-out with everything you have on board.

With SOLAS you have to go chapter by chapter. Its regulation I/3 leaves out, unless expressly provided otherwise, pleasure yachts not engaged in tradeSOLAS, regulation I/3, BOE-A-1980-12179 (in Spanish). So the boat places of chapter III, the subdivision of II-1 and the radio of IV do not apply to a yacht in that situation. Chapter V says of itself that it applies to all ships on any voyage, with the exceptions it lists. How all this reaches your craft in Spain, and what safety equipment you must carry, is set by Spanish regulations, which this text does not review. What you read here is general information, not legal advice.

Rule 6: Safe speed

What it means
Always proceed at a speed that lets you manoeuvre effectively and stop within the distance the circumstances call for.
What happened
The Titanic was making about 22 knots at night, after ice warnings, and sighted the iceberg about 450 m off. Our verdict: she would breach it today.
Course lessonLook-out, speed and risk

Rule 5: Look-out

What it means
Keep a proper look-out by sight and hearing, using all available means that are appropriate.
What happened
There were two lookouts and an officer, without binoculars. From the reports we cannot decide whether the look-out was ‘proper’ (eficaz).
Course lessonLook-out, speed and risk

Annex IV: Distress signals

What it means
Lists the distress signals, among them rockets that throw red stars.
What happened
The Titanic’s rockets were white, as the 1912 rules allowed. Today they would fail in colour only.
Course lessonDistress signals

All of this is part of the PER syllabus; in the syllabus you have it split by topic. Rule 5 also appears in another case on this blog: the collision between a catamaran and a fishing boat off Mallorca.

How we made this analysis

The facts come from three documents: the British report of 1912, the US Senate report of the same year and the MAIB’s reappraisal of 1992 on the Californian. We read the first two in the transcription by the Titanic Inquiry Project; for the British one we checked 35 quotations against a scan of a printed edition of the time. We read today’s rules in the BOE on 16 November 2026: the consolidated COLREGs (RIPA) and the SOLAS and STCW amendments we cite. Each verdict compares the text of a rule with a fact from the reports. The verdicts are ours: they do not repeat the conclusions of the investigations, which we cite separately and as theirs, and they are not legal classifications. We use no names of people. The MAIB report is cited under its licence: “Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0”.

The reports do not agree on everything, and we have not chosen between them:

  • Time of the collision: 23:40 (British), 23:46 (Senate); the MAIB gives about 23:40 in one place and 23:45 in another.
  • Speed: about 22 knots (British), at least 21 (Senate).
  • Position: 41°46′ N, 50°14′ W in 1912; the MAIB places the collision near 41°47′ N, 49°55′ W.
  • People on board and saved: 2,201 and 711 (British); 2,223 and 706 (Senate).
  • Boat places: 1,178 (British); 1,176 (Senate).
  • Length: 852.5 ft registered length (British); 882.6 ft (Senate).

What we could not read stays outside. The consolidated text of SOLAS published by the IMO is behind a paywall, and we reviewed the later amendments to chapter III rule by rule, not line by line. Nor have we read the Polar Code or how these rules apply to pleasure craft in Spain. And the reports do not describe the iceberg or give the exact time of the lookout’s warning. This is general information, not legal advice.

Frequently asked questions

Why did the Titanic sink?

She struck an iceberg at night while making about 22 knots. The ice opened the starboard side below the waterline along about 91 metres, and within ten minutes there was water in five forward compartments. She sank at 02:20, two hours and forty minutes later. The British report of 1912 attributed the loss to a collision with an iceberg, brought about by the excessive speed at which she was being navigated, and stated that it could not blame the captain, who was following the usual practice of the time.

What is the SOLAS Convention, and what does it have to do with the Titanic?

It is the International Convention for the Safety of Life at Sea (SOLAS). According to the IMO, its first version was adopted in 1914 in response to the sinking of the Titanic. The one in force is that of 1974, amended many times, and Spain publishes it in the BOE. Among other things it sets the boats and liferafts of a passenger ship, her abandon-ship drills and her radio.

What are the COLREGs, or RIPA in Spain?

They are the International Regulations for Preventing Collisions at Sea of 1972, known in Spain as the RIPA. They contain the rules on look-out, speed, manoeuvring, lights and signals for all vessels, pleasure craft included. Spain published them in the BOE in 1977.

What happened to the Californian?

That steamer lay stopped among the ice that night and, according to both reports, rockets were seen from her. The British court of 1912 concluded that she could have reached the Titanic had she tried on seeing the first one, and that she did not try. The MAIB reviewed the case in 1992 and its two inspectors did not agree: one placed the Californian between 5 and 7 miles away; the other, backed by the chief inspector, between 17 and 20, so far that going would hardly have changed the result, although he maintained that the attempt should have been made. We give no verdict on the Californian: the two reports do not agree and we cite them for what they are, the conclusions of their authors. Today SOLAS regulation V/33 obliges a master who, being in a position to help, receives information that people are in danger at sea to proceed at full speed to their assistance; if the master cannot, or does not consider it reasonable or necessary, the reason must be entered in the logbook.